All-Northern 10 Athletic Conference Football
As voted on by N10 coaches
| 1st team offense | School | Yr | Po |
| Andon Clouse | Mohawk | 11 | QB |
| Nicholas Parks | Seneca East | 12 | QB |
| Mace Puckett | Carey | 11 | RB |
| Connor McMichael | Colonel Crawford | 12 | RB |
| Kaden Bish | Mohawk | 11 | RB |
| Parker Weithman | Colonel Crawford | 11 | WR |
| Levi Tiell | Mohawk | 10 | WR |
| Josh Heilman | Upper Sandusky | 12 | WR |
| Levi Bowling | Carey | 10 | OL |
| Garrett Boes | Carey | 12 | OL |
| Payne DeGray | Colonel Crawford | 12 | OL |
| Eli Chevalier | Mohawk | 12 | OL |
| Mason Holmer | Seneca East | 12 | OL |
| 1st team defense | School | Yr | Po |
| Carter Bame | Carey | 12 | DL |
| Payne DeGray | Colonel Crawford | 12 | DL |
| Kaden Bish | Mohawk | 11 | DL |
| Eli Chevalier | Mohawk | 12 | DL |
| Bryce Locker | Wynford | 12 | DL |
| Dash Puckett | Carey | 12 | LB |
| Mace Puckett | Carey | 11 | LB |
| Owen Patrizi | Mohawk | 12 | LB |
| Jackson Gayheart | Seneca East | 11 | LB |
| Ethan Lewis | Upper Sandusky | 12 | LB |
| Tripp Phoenix | Carey | 11 | DB |
| John DeGray | Colonel Crawford | 11 | DB |
| Brant Kirian | Mohawk | 12 | DB |
| 1st team special | School | Yr | Po |
| Josh Heilman | Upper Sandusky | 12 | P |
| Joseph Zizzo | Colonel Crawford | 12 | K |
| Kobe Beidelschies | Upper Sandusky | 10 | K |
Offensive player of the year
Andon Clouse, Mohawk
Defensive player of the year
Payne DeGray, Colonel Crawford
Special teams co-players of the year
Kobe Beidelschies, Upper Sandusky; and Joseph Zizzo, Colonel Crawford
Coach of the year
Jonathon Mershman, Carey
| 2nd team offense | School | Yr | Po |
| Jack Phillips | Buckeye Central | 12 | QB |
| Dash Puckett | Carey | 12 | RB |
| Jackson Gayheart | Seneca East | 11 | RB |
| Ethan Lewis | Upper Sandusky | 12 | RB |
| Bryce Locker | Wynford | 12 | RB |
| Bostyn Ritter | Carey | 12 | WR |
| Brant Kirian | Mohawk | 12 | WR |
| Alec Phillips | Buckeye Central | 12 | WR |
| Chase Stone | Carey | 12 | OL |
| Dom Dean | Colonel Crawford | 12 | OL |
| Logan Hemminger | Mohawk | 12 | OL |
| Logan Fichtner | Wynford | 12 | OL |
| Derek Barr | Upper Sandusky | 12 | OL |
| 2nd team defense | School | Yr | Po |
| Louis Watkins | Carey | 11 | DL |
| Logan Hemminger | Mohawk | 12 | DL |
| Hunter Rathburn | Seneca East | 12 | DL |
| Mason Holmer | Seneca East | 12 | DL |
| Derek Barr | Upper Sandusky | 12 | DL |
| Connor McMichael | Colonel Crawford | 12 | LB |
| Gabe Stratton | Colonel Crawford | 10 | LB |
| Braxton Rimmer | Upper Sandusky | 11 | LB |
| Hayden Butcher | Bucyrus | 11 | LB |
| Maddax Engler | Wynford | 11 | LB |
| Logan Summit | Carey | 11 | DB |
| Roen Thew | Colonel Crawford | 11 | DB |
| Ezekiel Baldwin | Upper Sandusky | 11 | DB |
| Louis Watkins | Carey | 11 | DL |
| 2nd team special | School | Yr | Po |
| Andon Clouse | Mohawk | 11 | P |
| Honorable mention | School | Yr | Po |
| Dylan Heydinger | Buckeye Central | 11 | OL/DL |
| Lance Cole | Buckeye Central | 12 | OL/DL |
| Christian Neal | Bucyrus | 12 | WR/DB |
| Wyatt Makeever | Bucyrus | 10 | RB/LB |
| Kyler Boes | Carey | 12 | TE/LB |
| Eli Steen | Carey | 12 | RB/DL |
| Peyton Baker | Colonel Crawford | 12 | QB |
| Brayden Holt | Colonel Crawford | 12 | QB |
| Mason Schimpf | Mohawk | 12 | WR/DB |
| Brady Coffman | Mohawk | 12 | OL/DL |
| Elijah Cline | Seneca East | 11 | RB/LB |
| Landyn Hicks | Seneca East | 11 | OL/DL |
| Kasen Gottfried | Upper Sandusky | 11 | WR/DB |
| Caine Rupe | Upper Sandusky | 10 | WR/DB |
| Zaidin Zier | Wynford | 11 | RB/DB |
| Jake Stover | Wynford | 12 | TE/DL |