All-Northern 10 Athletic Conference Football
| 1st team offense | School | Yr | Po |
| Andon Clouse | Mohawk | 12 | QB |
| Keegan Dunn | Upper Sandusky | 12 | QB |
| Branson Robinson | Seneca East | 10 | QB |
| Tripp Phoenix | Carey | 12 | QB |
| Kellen Frankart | Hopewell-Loudon | 12 | RB |
| Mace Puckett | Carey | 12 | RB |
| Kaden Bish | Mohawk | 12 | RB |
| Jackson Gayheart | Seneca East | 12 | RB |
| Levi Tiell | Mohawk | 11 | WR |
| Parker Weithman | Colonel Crawford | 12 | WR |
| Brody Brickman | Hopewell-Loudon | 12 | WR |
| Kasen Gottfried | Upper Sandusky | 12 | WR |
| Jaron Depinet | Seneca East | 10 | WR |
| Reese Alt | Hopewell-Loudon | 11 | TE |
| Brayden Williams | Carey | 12 | TE |
| Joe Ewald | Hopewell-Loudon | 12 | OT |
| Brayson Leiter | Hopewell-Loudon | 11 | OT |
| Skyler McFadden | Carey | 11 | OT |
| Landyn Hicks | Seneca East | 12 | OT |
| Cooper Smith | Hopewell-Loudon | 12 | OG |
| Caleb Putnam | Carey | 11 | OG |
| Brody Sealey | Seneca East | 12 | OG |
| Lane Riley | Colonel Crawford | 11 | OG |
| Wyatt King | Mohawk | 11 | C |
| Brayden Francis | Lucas | 12 | C |
| 1st team defense | School | Yr | Po |
| Cooper Smith | Hopewell-Loudon | 12 | DT |
| Brayson Leiter | Hopewell-Loudon | 11 | DT |
| Caleb Putnam | Carey | 11 | DT |
| Connor Eader | Mohawk | 10 | NT |
| Louis Watkins | Carey | 12 | DE |
| Joe Ewald | Hopewell-Loudon | 12 | DE |
| Luke Christman | Colonel Crawford | 12 | DE |
| Landyn Hicks | Seneca East | 12 | DE |
| Mace Puckett | Carey | 12 | ILB |
| Jackson Gayheart | Seneca East | 12 | ILB |
| Aden Patrizi | Mohawk | 11 | ILB |
| Joe Reinhart | Carey | 10 | ILB |
| Kaden Bish | Mohawk | 12 | OLB |
| Tyler Lash | Colonel Crawford | 12 | OLB |
| Braylon Ramirez | Hopewell-Loudon | 11 | OLB |
| Shawn Pierce | Hopewell-Loudon | 11 | OLB |
| Levi Tiell | Mohawk | 11 | CB |
| Parker Weithman | Colonel Crawford | 12 | CB |
| Tripp Phoenix | Carey | 12 | CB |
| Kasen Gottfried | Upper Sandusky | 12 | CB |
| Brody Brickman | Hopewell-Loudon | 12 | S |
| Roen Thew | Colonel Crawford | 12 | S |
| Logan Summit | Carey | 12 | S |
| Levi Dawson | Seneca East | 11 | S |
| 1st team special teams | School | Yr | Po |
| Kobe Beidelschies | Upper Sandusky | 11 | K |
| Cam Lucius | Calvert | 12 | P |
| Parker Weithman | Colonel Crawford | 12 | RET |
| Offensive player of the year: Kellen Frankart, Hopewell-Loudon | |||
| Co-defensive players of the year: Louis Watkins, Carey; and Joe Ewald, Hopewell-Loudon | |||
| Special teams player of the year: Kobe Beidelschies, Upper Sandusky | |||
| Coach of the year: Brian Colatruglio, Hopewell-Loudon | |||
| 2nd team offense | School | Yr | Po |
| Jacoby Ellis | Hopewell-Loudon | 12 | QB |
| Braylon Wells | Wynford | 10 | QB |
| Avery Powers | Colonel Crawford | 11 | RB |
| Brady Guegold | Lucas | 12 | RB |
| Deegan Lutz | Wynford | 12 | RB |
| Wyatt Makeever | Bucyrus | 11 | RB |
| Jagger Ekleberry | Mohawk | 12 | WR |
| Chase Rogier | Hopewell-Loudon | 12 | WR |
| Caine Rupe | Upper Sandusky | 11 | WR |
| Rhett Leeth | Mohawk | 11 | TE |
| Hayden Butcher | Bucyrus | 12 | TE |
| Luke Christman | Colonel Crawford | 12 | OT |
| Joey Culler | Lucas | 12 | OT |
| Kasey Coffman | Mohawk | 10 | OT |
| Stuart Smith | Lucas | 10 | OG |
| Alex Gelbaugh | Upper Sandusky | 11 | OG |
| Trenton Ritter | Carey | 10 | OG |
| Grayson Burgei | Carey | 11 | C |
| Wyatt Stahl | Wynford | 10 | C |
| 2nd team defense | School | Yr | Po |
| Bekkem Sherman | Carey | 12 | DT |
| Bentley Gayheart | Seneca East | 10 | DT |
| Jett Loesser | Mohawk | 12 | DT |
| Eli Cline | Seneca East | 12 | DE |
| Wyatt Kennedy | Upper Sandusky | 12 | DE |
| Brayden Williams | Carey | 12 | DE |
| Roger Whetstone | Willard | 11 | ILB |
| Andon Clouse | Mohawk | 11 | ILB |
| Hayden Butcher | Bucyrus | 12 | ILB |
| Brady Guegold | Lucas | 12 | OLB |
| Rhett Leeth | Mohawk | 11 | OLB |
| Trevin Cottingham | Seneca East | 11 | OLB |
| Isaac Makeever | Bucyrus | 10 | OLB |
| Ezekiel Baldwin | Upper Sandusky | 12 | OLB |
| Reiyc Hoover | Hopewell-Loudon | 12 | CB |
| Holden Parker | Mohawk | 12 | CB |
| Lukas Stultz | Calvert | 12 | CB |
| Braylon Wells | Wynford | 10 | S |
| Wyatt Makeever | Bucyrus | 11 | S |
| Travis Klaus | Upper Sandusky | 11 | S |
| 2nd team special teams | School | Yr | Po |
| Aden Patrizi | Mohawk | 11 | K |
| Colton McConnell | Seneca East | 10 | P |
| Reiyc Hoover | Hopewell-Loudon | 12 | RET |
| Honorable mention offense | School | Yr | Po |
| Roen Thew | Colonel Crawford | 12 | QB |
| Isaac Makeever | Bucyrus | 10 | QB |
| Brady Anschutz | Lucas | 11 | RB |
| Cooper Day | Lucas | 12 | RB |
| Logan Summit | Carey | 12 | WR |
| Travis Klaus | Upper Sandusky | 11 | WR |
| Izaiah Higgins | Upper Sandusky | 11 | OT |
| Hayden Hafner | Buckeye Central | 10 | OT |
| Ethan Baugher | Calvert | 11 | OT |
| Carson Witten | Bucyrus | 12 | OG |
| Cole Seifert | Calvert | 11 | OG |
| Dylan Heydinger | Buckeye Central | 12 | C |
| Honorable mention defense | School | Yr | Po |
| Jamison Crall | Wynford | 11 | DT |
| Ben Hockensmith | Lucas | 10 | DT |
| Lucas Alspach | Upper Sandusky | 12 | DE |
| Ethan Baugher | Calvert | 11 | DE |
| Braxton Rimmer | Upper Sandusky | 12 | ILB |
| Gabe Stratton | Colonel Crawford | 11 | ILB |
| Kyle Smith | Colonel Crawford | 11 | OLB |
| Joey Desterhaft | Lucas | 12 | CB |
| Eli Cooper | Wynford | 12 | CB |
| Cooper Day | Lucas | 12 | S |
| Colton McConnell | Seneca East | 10 | S |
| Jamison Crall | Wynford | 11 | DT |
| Honorable Mention special teams | School | Yr | Po |
| Isaac Stockmaster | Seneca East | 10 | K |
| Luke Christman | Colonel Crawford | 12 | P |
| Da’Shawn Cosey | Bucyrus | 11 | RET |