Listed are the Colonel Crawford High School students that made the Honor or Merit Rolls for the first quarter of the 2016-2017 school year.
| 12th Grade Honor Roll |
| Bradley Bauer |
| Kaitlyn Bilsing |
| Jessica Brocwell |
| Grant Carman |
| Rhianna Clark |
| Cade Coffman |
| Claire Ehmann |
| Ally Ferguson |
| Emily Hadsell |
| Alexander Hershey |
| Stefanie Huggins |
| Malachi Israel |
| Emily Kemper |
| Owen Kocher |
| Joshua Leuthold |
| Kirsten Lewis |
| Jakeb Lohr |
| Ashleigh Mills |
| Samantha Mutchler |
| Anna Reffey |
| Kerri Reynolds |
| Elaina Sellman |
| Madison Sharp |
| Devin Starlin |
| Austin Strouse |
| Ethan Studer |
| Nicholas Studer |
| Abbi Teglovic |
| Kirsten Vehrs |
| 12th Grade Merit Roll |
| Kristy Barker |
| Allison Boyer |
| Abbie Bradshaw |
| Hannah Breyley |
| Allison Burger |
| Alexus Burkhart |
| Nicholas Campbell |
| Maegan Chandler |
| Jordan Dailey |
| Megan Daubenspeck |
| Jared Furr |
| Austin Gies |
| Nicholas Graham |
| Kendyl Guinther |
| Hunter Hall |
| Matthew Hopkins |
| Jakeb Johnson |
| Sydney Lemaster |
| Shelby McCleese |
| Cameron Spangler |
| Heath Starkey |
| Jaret Tinkey |
| Lexi Wireman |
| 11th Grade Honor Roll |
| Emily Baker |
| Sabrina Burn |
| Chloe Carman |
| Amanda Crase |
| Joczelyn Earl |
| Kiersten Erwin |
| Marcus Fagan |
| Kaleb Haynes |
| Caitlin Koschnick |
| Pierce Krassow |
| Karlie Kurtzman |
| Lori Millenbaugh |
| Tayler Miller |
| Alyssa Payne |
| Cieara Pfeifer |
| Madison Rinehart |
| Jennifer Siegel |
| Brooke Stephenson |
| Elizabeth Striker |
| Lydia Strouse |
| Sydney Studer |
| Kari Teglovic |
| Caden Trubee |
| 11th Grade Merit Roll |
| Andrew Bishop |
| Courtney Britt |
| Sarah Campbell |
| Brianna Church |
| Makayla Davis |
| Drake DeLong |
| Gwyneth Ferguson |
| Kenneth Fernandez |
| Jensyn Fredritz |
| Raye Hershey |
| Wade Hopkins |
| Katelyn Jones |
| Brody Martin |
| Isabelle Moening |
| Presley Mullet |
| Spencer Mutchler |
| Skylar Parsons |
| Rebecca Pfleiderer |
| Leira Satterthwaite |
| Desiree Sharp |
| Cameron Smith |
| 10th Grade Honor Roll |
| Elizabeth Adams |
| Hali Bailey |
| Brevin Balliett |
| Nicholas Barnes |
| Melany Bocka |
| Chelsea Cook |
| Madisyn Cooke |
| Jessika Cotsmire |
| Bailey Dixon |
| Ian Dzugan |
| Andrew Geiger |
| Reegyn Goyer |
| Danielle Horsley |
| Zoe Kalb |
| Aaron King |
| Zachary Moritz |
| Kyle Nebergall |
| Bailey Niedermier |
| Keton Pfeifer |
| Victoria Shipman |
| Kennedy Speck |
| Madison Tieben |
| Makenna Vermillion |
| Isabella Walter |
| Melia Williamson |
| Nathan Wingert |
| 10th Grade Merit Roll |
| Brandon Bauer |
| Andrew Brause |
| Raven Crawford |
| Andrew Daubenspeck |
| Dylan David |
| Dakota Gattshall |
| Jillianne Gregg |
| Latasha Gross |
| Dine Hilbrandt |
| Olivia Hocker |
| Braxton James |
| Andrew Johnson |
| Haley Laughbaum |
| Courtney Lyons |
| Alyssa Mills |
| Sadie Moss |
| Ciera Pfeifer |
| Hailey Ratliff |
| Dylan Rider |
| Owin Seevers |
| Madalon Shade |
| Philip Sherman |
| Bruce Shull |
| Dylan Spears |
| Isabella Stalter |
| Jonah Studer |
| Antonio Wegener |
| 9th Grade Honor Roll |
| Daylen Balliett |
| Sarah Beck |
| Allison Brause |
| Abbie Brocwell |
| Trevor Chance |
| Mariah Cotsamire |
| Alec Deeb |
| Macie Dicus |
| Lydia Feik |
| Rachael Forsythe |
| Katie Hopkins |
| Alexander Lawson |
| Madelyn Massie |
| Elena McCoy |
| Cameron McCreary |
| Brianna Morton |
| Alex Mutchler |
| Daniel Shambaugh |
| Hope Sharp |
| Megan Shull |
| Nate Tanner |
| Bailey Wallace |
| Morgan Walsh |
| Hannah Willacker |
| 9th Grade Merit Roll |
| Latasha Bays |
| Alan Burkhart |
| Alana Burkhart |
| Chandler Cobb |
| Addison Conkle |
| Trevin Fairchild |
| Jordan Fenner |
| Madison Furr |
| Taylor Garrison-Wise |
| Trinity Gatten |
| Owen Green |
| Katrina Haycook |
| Drew Krassow |
| Olivia Marks |
| Kheira McClanahan |
| Seth Miller |
| Logan Rinehart |
| Maci Risner |
| Blake Scribner |
| Reis Walker |
| Cecilia Wurm |